AI wins state truthful artwork contest, annoys people


An AI-generated image that won a prize at the Colorado State Fair
Enlarge / The profitable entry, Théåtre D’opéra Spatial.

Jason Allen

An artificial media artist named Jason Allen entered AI-generated paintings into the Colorado State Truthful advantageous arts competitors and introduced final week that he gained first place within the Digital Arts/Digitally Manipulated Pictures class, Vice reported Wednesday based mostly on a viral tweet.

Allen used Midjourney—a industrial picture synthesis mannequin accessible by a Discord server—to create a collection of three photographs. He then upscaled them, printed them on canvas, and submitted them to the competitors in early August. To his delight, one of many photographs (titled Théåtre D’opéra Spatial) captured the highest prize, and he posted about his victory on the Midjourney Discord server on Friday.

Allen’s Discord post announcing victory.
Enlarge / Allen’s Discord submit asserting victory.

MidJourney Discord

Allen’s victory prompted energetic discussions on Twitter, Reddit, and the Midjourney Discord server in regards to the nature of artwork and what it means to be an artist. Some commenters assume human artistry is doomed because of AI and that each one artists are destined to be changed by machines. Others assume artwork will evolve and adapt with new applied sciences that come alongside, citing synthesizers in music. It is a sizzling debate that Wired lined in July.

There’s additionally the equity aspect because it is not clear if Allen advised the judges about his use of picture synthesis, although some Twitter customers have reportedly contacted the judges and found that they did not know. Curiously, the artwork was thought-about ok to idiot human artists, and somebody on Twitter joked that it settled the talk over “whether or not AI artwork is artwork.”

It is value noting that the invention of the digicam within the 1800s prompted comparable criticism associated to the medium of pictures, for the reason that digicam seemingly did all of the work in comparison with an artist that labored to craft an paintings by hand with a brush or pencil. Some feared that painters would eternally turn into out of date with the appearance of coloration pictures. In some purposes, pictures changed extra laborious illustration strategies (similar to engraving), however human advantageous artwork painters are nonetheless round at the moment.

Picture synthesis instruments of their present state require a excessive diploma of human steering and cherry-picking to attain outstanding outcomes, however the area is evolving quickly, and which may not all the time be the case. Nonetheless, so long as new inventive instruments emerge, the “Is it artwork?” debate will probably proceed so long as there are folks to have the dialogue.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Share post:


More like this